A member of staff on the late shift believes a fourteen-year-old has a blade hidden in her bedroom. She has self-harmed before. She is in the lounge, refusing to talk, and her bedroom door is shut. In the next ten minutes, the team will decide whether to ask her, whether to search her room, and what to do if she stands in the doorway and says no. Few everyday moments in a children's home move so quickly from a conversation to a physical intervention.
At ProActive Approaches, we look at these moments through #AimingForZero, the position our founder Simon Gower has held since 2016. A reduction target implies there is a number of restraints that is acceptable. Zero removes that permission, and it changes what a team asks after an incident. Searches and the removal of items are one of the places where that question matters most, because so many restraints begin not with a child hurting someone, but with an adult trying to take something from them.
Regulation 20 of the Children's Homes (England) Regulations 2015 permits restraint only to prevent injury to any person or serious damage to property, and it must be necessary and proportionate. That is the floor. Finding an item, enforcing a house rule or winning an argument about a phone is not, on its own, a permitted reason to restrain a child. This guide, part of our wider series on physical intervention training for children's homes, is about the work above that floor.
Key takeaways
- Many restraints start with an attempt to search a child or take an item from them, so searching practice is restraint reduction practice.
- Regulation 20 only permits restraint to prevent injury or serious damage. Retrieving an item is not a reason in its own right.
- Regulation 21 requires any limit on a child's privacy to be necessary, proportionate, kept under review and as freeing as safety allows.
- The government's guide to the regulations says rooms should usually only be searched after the child has been told or asked for permission.
- Planning, relationships and honest conversations remove most of the need for force before a search ever begins.
Why searching is a restraint question
When teams review their incident records, a pattern often appears. A child is believed to have something: a lighter, a blade, cannabis, a phone being used to contact someone who is exploiting them. Staff ask for it. The child refuses. Staff insist. Within minutes, the child is distressed, the staff are anxious and somebody's hand is on somebody's arm. The incident is recorded as a restraint to prevent injury, but it began as a search.
That matters because the moment of escalation was chosen by the adults. The child did not start by hurting anyone. The adults started by trying to take something. In many cases, there were other ways to reduce the risk that did not require the item to be removed at that exact moment.
This is not an argument against searching. Some items genuinely put children at serious risk, and leaving them in place can be its own failure of care. Ofsted inspection reports have criticised homes where staff avoided searches because they feared how a child would respond, leaving risky items in a bedroom for weeks. The point is that the decision to search, and how a search is carried out, should be planned as carefully as any other moment that could lead to physical intervention.
What the law and guidance actually say
There are three pieces that every residential team should understand together.
Regulation 20: the purpose test
Restraint is only permitted for the purpose of preventing injury to any person, including the child, or serious damage to the property of any person. In secure children's homes it may also be used to prevent absconding. It must be necessary and proportionate. Nothing in the regulation permits restraint to retrieve an item, to complete a search or to enforce a rule. If a child is physically held during a search, the record has to show what injury or serious damage was being prevented, and why nothing less restrictive would have worked.
Regulation 21: privacy and its limits
Regulation 21 requires the registered person to ensure that children's privacy is appropriately protected. Any limitation placed on a child's privacy must be intended to safeguard children, be necessary and proportionate, be kept under review and allow children as much freedom as possible when balanced against the need to keep them safe. A search is a limit on privacy. A blanket rule that every room is searched after every missing episode is very hard to reconcile with this regulation.
The guide to the regulations: tell or ask first
The government's Guide to the Children's Homes Regulations, including the quality standards says, at paragraph 3.20, that a child's bedroom should not generally be entered without their permission. Usually, rooms should only be searched if the child has been informed or asked for their permission. Immediate searching may be necessary where there are reasonable grounds for believing there is a risk to the child's or another person's safety or wellbeing.
The Regulations do not set out a specific power to search a child. Homes should have a clear written procedure, agreed with leaders and understood by every member of staff, which reflects the guidance above and the child's individual plans.
Prevention before any search
The most effective way to avoid physical intervention during a search is to make most searches unnecessary, and to make the rest predictable.
Make safe storage the normal option
The guide expects children to have somewhere secure to store personal items. When a child has a lockable space that is genuinely theirs, staff can also agree with them where certain items will be kept safely, such as medication, chargers or sharp tools for a hobby. Children who feel their belongings are respected are more likely to hand something over when asked.
Agree the approach in the child's plans
If a child is known to conceal items they use to hurt themselves, or to bring items back after going missing, that risk belongs in their behaviour support plan and risk assessment. Write down, with the child where possible, what staff will do if they are worried. Who will ask? How? Where will the conversation happen? What will the child be offered instead of the item? A child who has helped write the plan is far less likely to experience a search as an ambush.
Ask before you search
The first and most powerful step is a calm, private conversation. "I'm worried you might have something in your room that could hurt you. Can we look together?" said by a trusted adult, at the right time, often ends the matter without a search at all. Many children will hand an item over if they are given a dignified way to do it and are not punished for doing so.
Reduce the risk without taking the item
Not every concern needs immediate removal. Increasing supervision, staying with the child, offering a different activity, contacting the child's social worker or simply waiting until the child is calmer can lower the risk while the conversation continues. The question is not "how do we get it now?" but "what is the least restrictive way to keep everyone safe right now?"
When a search does happen
Where a search is justified, how it is carried out makes the difference between a safe experience and an incident.
- Tell the child, and ask for their permission. Explain why, in plain language, and offer them the chance to be present.
- Agree roles first. One adult talks and the other searches. Decide in advance who will step back if the child becomes distressed.
- Respect dignity. Treat belongings carefully, put things back as you found them, and avoid searching in front of other children.
- Know when to stop. If the child's distress is rising and there is no immediate risk of injury, pause. A search can be resumed later. A restraint cannot be undone.
- Involve leaders. Searches without the child's knowledge or agreement should have management oversight of the decision.
Children who have experienced abuse may experience a search of their room, or of their person, as a profound violation. Staff should think about the child's history, gender, culture and any trauma before deciding who should be involved and how close they need to be.
If a child refuses to hand something over
This is the moment where most restraint begins, so it needs the clearest thinking.
Ask first: is there an immediate risk of injury or serious damage? If a child is holding a blade against their skin, the answer may be yes, and the home's plan for that child should already describe the safest response. If a child refuses to hand over a phone, a vape or a bag that staff suspect contains cannabis, the answer is usually no. Those concerns are serious, but they do not meet the purpose test in Regulation 20 on their own, and holding the child is unlikely to be proportionate.
In those situations, staff have other options. They can stay with the child, keep talking, remove other children from the area, contact the manager on call, inform the child's social worker and, where a crime may have been committed or there is serious risk of exploitation, seek advice from the police. None of these options requires anyone to be physically held.
Where physical intervention is genuinely necessary to prevent injury, it must be the minimum force for the shortest time, carried out by staff trained to recognised standards. The Restraint Reduction Network Training Standards set out what certified training should cover, including the prevention and de-escalation work that sits before any hold. Our physical intervention training is built around that order of priorities.
Searches after a child returns from missing
Some homes routinely search a child's room or belongings every time they return from a missing episode. Ofsted has criticised this where it is applied to every child regardless of their individual risks. A child who comes back tired, frightened or ashamed and is immediately searched may learn that coming home leads to confrontation, which can make the next missing episode longer.
A better approach is to assess the risk for that child, on that return. A warm welcome, food, a return conversation and a check on the child's wellbeing come first. If there are reasonable grounds to believe the child has brought back something dangerous, the search should still follow the same principles: tell, ask, involve and record. Our guide to physical intervention and children going missing covers the wider picture.
Recording and review
Inspection reports return again and again to the same gaps in search records. Good records show:
- the reason for the search and the risk it was intended to reduce;
- whether the child was told, whether their permission was sought, and their response;
- whether the child was present, and if not, why not;
- what was found, what was removed, where it is kept and the plan for returning it;
- management oversight of the decision;
- any physical intervention, recorded in full as a restraint in line with the home's restraint recording duties.
Leaders should review searches in the same way they review restraints. How many searches were there this month? How many found nothing? How many led to physical intervention? Which children are searched most, and what does that tell us about their plans? A home that is aiming for zero treats every search that turned physical as a learning event, and asks what could have happened earlier.
Talking to the child afterwards
Every search, and especially any search that involved physical intervention, should be followed by a conversation. Explain what happened and why. Listen to how the child experienced it. Agree what would make the next time different. Return items when it is safe to do so, and tell the child the plan. Children who feel heard after a search are more likely to cooperate with the next one, and less likely to hide things in the first place.
What training should cover
Searching is rarely covered well in generic physical intervention courses, yet it is one of the most common triggers for restraint in residential care. Training for children's homes should help staff to:
- understand the purpose test in Regulation 20 and why retrieving an item does not meet it on its own;
- apply Regulation 21 and paragraph 3.20 of the guide in everyday decisions;
- plan searches with children, not just around them;
- recognise rising distress early and step back before force becomes the only option;
- record searches clearly and review them as part of restraint reduction.
Physical intervention is the smallest part of what a home does about distressed behaviour, and the only part most training covers well. Our work targets everything that sits before it. That approach has a documented track record of reductions of up to 80 per cent in restraint use, and it applies just as much to the bedroom doorway as to the lounge.
Frequently asked questions
Can staff in a children's home search a child's bedroom without permission?
Usually, rooms should only be searched if the child has been told or asked for their permission. The guide to the regulations recognises that immediate searching may be necessary where there are reasonable grounds to believe there is a risk to the child's or another person's safety or wellbeing. Any search without permission should be justified, overseen by a manager and recorded.
Can a child be restrained so that staff can search them?
Regulation 20 only permits restraint to prevent injury or serious damage to property, and it must be necessary and proportionate. Completing a search or retrieving an item is not a permitted purpose in its own right. If there is an immediate risk of injury, the child's plan should describe the safest response, and any restraint must be recorded in full.
Should we search every child after they return from missing?
No. Searches should be based on an assessment of the individual child's needs and risks on that occasion. Blanket search rules are difficult to justify under Regulation 21 and have been criticised by Ofsted.
What should a search record include?
The reason for the search, whether the child was told or asked, whether they were present, what was found and removed, management oversight, the plan for returning items and details of any physical intervention.
Every search is a moment where a home can either build trust or lose it. Planning searches with children, asking before acting and stepping back when there is no immediate danger are how a home keeps searching safe. Aiming for zero means treating the doorway of a child's bedroom as one of the places where restraint is prevented, not where it begins.
