Prone restraint risks and safer alternatives in children's homes

Prone restraint means holding a person face down. In children's homes it is one of the most closely scrutinised forms of physical intervention, because of the risk it poses to a child's breathing. It is not illegal, but any use of it has to be explained, and many homes now choose never to use it on purpose.

Simon Gower

5 min read

Watercolour illustration of a friendly children's residential care worker in a calm homely living room, representing safer alternatives to prone restraint in UK children's homes.

Prone restraint means holding a person face down. In children's homes it is one of the most closely scrutinised forms of physical intervention, because of the risk it poses to a child's breathing. It is not illegal, but any use of it has to be explained, and many homes now choose never to use it on purpose.

This article sets out what the guidance says, why the position is dangerous, which children are at greater risk, and what safer alternatives look like in practice.

Key points

  • Prone holds are lawful but high risk. Ofsted expects any use to be explored and justified.
  • The danger is to breathing. Weight on the back, chest or abdomen can stop a child breathing effectively within a short time.
  • If a child ends up on the floor, release or reposition quickly. That is the clear expectation in both Ofsted and government guidance.

What the guidance says

Ofsted's guidance for inspectors and providers on restraint lists prone or "ground" holds, and deliberately taking children to the floor, among the practices it will look at closely. It states that these holds are not illegal, and that a child who drops to the floor during a hold has not necessarily been held prone. It then adds that the hold can restrict breathing and that any use must be explored.

The same guidance says children should not be restrained in a way that affects their airway, breathing or circulation, for example by covering the mouth or nose or putting pressure on the neck or abdomen. If a child is unintentionally held on the ground, staff should release or move to a safer position, including standing, as quickly as possible. A medical check should follow where appropriate.

The Department of Health and Social Care and Department for Education's 2019 guidance, Reducing the need for restraint and restrictive intervention, takes the same line for children with learning disabilities, autism and mental health needs across health, social care and special education.

The legal test in a children's home stays the same throughout. Regulation 20 of the Children's Homes (England) Regulations 2015 allows restraint only to prevent injury or serious damage to property, and only where it is necessary and proportionate. A face-down hold has to meet that test for every second it lasts.

Why the position is dangerous

Breathing depends on the chest and diaphragm being free to move. Face down, a child's own body weight already limits that movement. Add the weight of one or more adults on the back, shoulders or hips and breathing can become shallow and ineffective. This is called positional asphyxia, and it can happen quickly.

The risk is made worse because the signs are easy to miss. A child who is struggling may be fighting for air rather than resisting. Staff focused on control may not see the face. A child who goes quiet may be losing consciousness rather than calming down.

Children at higher risk

  • children who have been running, fighting or struggling hard before the hold;
  • children with asthma, heart conditions, epilepsy or other health needs;
  • children carrying extra weight, or very small children held by larger adults;
  • children who have taken alcohol or drugs, or are on certain medications;
  • children who cannot easily tell staff they are in difficulty, including those with communication needs.

Psychological harm

Being pinned face down is frightening for anyone. For a child with a history of abuse it can feel like a repeat of past harm. Even when no physical injury results, the impact on the child's trust in staff can last far longer than the incident.

Safer alternatives

Prevent the need for a hold

The safest hold is the one that never happens. That rests on knowing each child's triggers and early signs, having an up-to-date behaviour support plan, and giving staff the confidence to use space, time and choice. Our de-escalation training focuses on these skills.

Choose the least restrictive option

Where some physical support is unavoidable, guiding or escorting a child, or a brief standing hold, carries much less risk than any ground hold. Staff should know which techniques are authorised for each child, and why.

Plan what happens if a child goes to the floor

Children do sometimes drop or fall during a hold. Teams should rehearse what to do: release weight immediately, keep the airway clear, and move to sitting, kneeling alongside or standing, or let go entirely if it is safe. Nobody should ever kneel, lie or lean on a child's back, chest, neck or abdomen.

Give one person the job of watching

If more than one adult is involved, one should take responsibility for watching the child's face, breathing and colour, and for calling an end to the hold. That person needs the authority to say "release now" and be listened to.

Check, record and review

After any hold that involved the floor, arrange a medical check where appropriate. Regulation 35 requires a written record within 24 hours, a conversation with the staff involved within 48 hours, and a conversation with the child within five days. Use the review to ask how the child came to be on the ground and what would stop it happening again. Our guide to post-incident debriefs after restraint sets out a structure.

What inspectors will want to see

Where a ground hold has happened, inspectors will want to understand why staff believed it was the best or only option, how it was proportionate, what impact it had on the child, and how the child's rights were respected. Leaders should be able to show that they review restraint records for patterns and act on poor practice.

Training matters here. Staff should be taught releases and repositioning as thoroughly as any hold, and that training should be certified against the RRN Training Standards. Our physical intervention training for children's homes is built on that basis, and our restraint reduction support helps homes bring their overall use of restraint down.

Common questions

Is prone restraint banned in children's homes?

No. It is not illegal, but it is high risk and must be justified each time. Many homes choose not to authorise it at all.

Does supine restraint (face up) avoid the risk?

It reduces some risks but introduces others, including pressure on the chest and danger if a child vomits. Any ground hold should be avoided where possible.

What if a child repeatedly drops to the floor?

Treat it as information. Review the child's plan, the holds being used and the situations that lead to them, and look for ways to avoid physical contact altogether.

← Back to all articles